The Secret Garden | Charming Highlands Eatery Known for Fresh Sandwiches Soups

Overview

Situated just off the main street in downtown Highlands, North Carolina, The Secret Garden is a culinary hideaway that lives up to its name. This charming restaurant offers a peaceful and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a leisurely lunch or a casual gathering with friends and family. Whether you choose to sit outside basking in the sunshine or enjoy the cozy interior, the space feels warm and welcoming to a diverse crowd—from business professionals and families with children to groups of friends and even dog owners.

The Secret Garden is best known for its thoughtfully prepared sandwiches and vibrant salads. Standouts like the chicken salad croissant and the vegetable-packed ciabatta roll showcase the kitchen’s commitment to fresh, well-balanced flavors. Sandwich lovers will also appreciate the Cuban and pastrami offerings, each crafted with care and rich flavor layers. The menu is rounded out with highlights such as butternut squash, tomato soup, and a uniquely satisfying street corn pasta salad, all made with fresh, seasonal ingredients.

One of the restaurant’s strengths lies in its authentic neighborhood feel, amplified by attentive service and a genuine connection to the community. The owner, a local mom, brings a nurturing energy that makes guests feel immediately at ease. The consistent quality has earned loyal patrons who gladly return again and again, often resisting the urge to stray from their favorite dishes. While waiting, the tempting array of fresh-baked goods, such as double chocolate muffins and oatmeal pies, offers an irresistible indulgence.

Ideal for those seeking a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience, The Secret Garden caters to a broad audience—from locals looking for a midday escape to visitors exploring Highlands. Its convenient location at 208 N 5th St makes it easily accessible for a spontaneous walk-in meal. With a menu that balances comfort food with fresh, seasonal choices, this spot proves to be a hidden gem worth discovering time and again.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Comfort food

Healthy options

Quick bite

Vegan options

Vegetarian options

Wine

Atmosphere

Casual

Cosy

Trendy

What Customers Say

Jessie B

Dec 11,2025

5/5

The Secret Garden is such a gem! We loved it so much we went two days in a row. The chicken salad on a croissant was absolutely delicious-fresh, flavorful, and perfectly portioned. The atmosphere is charming and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a leisurely lunch in downtown highlands. One of my favorite parts was being able to walk here. If you’re in the area, this is definitely a must-visit for a delicious lunch.

Andrea Gabbard

Dec 11,2025

5/5

We loved it! A Fun and hip place to relax and enjoy a wonderful meal. The fresh sandwiches are made to order.... and the slow simmered chicken noodle soup reminded me why we love soup. We already have plans to meet up twice a week - forever .... at the Secret Garden. Save 3 seats for us!

Catherine Moon

Dec 11,2025

5/5

I came with my two young, vocal sons and they didn’t flinch. They were accommodating and so kind — the owner is a mom with teenage boys who made me feel at ease. We sat outside and ate a delicious meal. There were families with dogs, groups of women, and business men all eating there. We will be back!

Jeannie Chambers

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Every time I go into The Secret Garden, I tell myself I’ll try something new, but… most of the time I get the same thing. The Godfather made as a salad is my top choice because it’s SO consistently and perfectly good. I’ve eaten inside, outside at provided tables and ordered to-go, and am always impressed with this small business. Whether I’m the only person in line (rare!) or in a snaky line of people, I always feel welcome. One caveat. If you’re left a few minutes in front of the deli case while you’re waiting on your meal, it’s very easy to succumb to the fresh baked goodies like the double chocolate muffins or oatmeal pies.

Ansel Strickland

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Sandwich of many vegetables on nice ciabatta roll, nicely tangy and properly seasoned. Not too expensive, freshly made and promptly delivered. Sat in the sun and enjoyed it. Restaurant is a block off the main street, and so it was peaceful place to be.

Jake Vinson

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Incredible food and service! Wide variety of sandwiches available, plus other unique food gifts. Whether you live around Highlands or are just passing through, the staff here is so welcoming and will make you feel at home!

Kedra McCall

Dec 11,2025

5/5

My favorite quick & easy lunch + place to order charcuterie boards & pastas for any event! Everything is always delicious & fresh + I love seeing all the team’s kind faces working hard. A great team, a great restaurant, a great patio to enjoy a meal!

Teresa Pittman-Wall

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Absolutely the hidden gem in Highlands! A tiny sandwich counter (with park side outdoor seating) that offers the best sandwiches for miles! It was even my choice for a birthday lunch (over all the fancy pants places) because the sandwiches are so delicious! Generous portions, fair prices, always friendly smiling staff, and consistent food taste. Thank you, Secret Garden for those qualities that are a rare find these days. #birthdaywin